Commentary

May 25, 2012

Some tax bills might be a mistake

by Gabriel Verhage
Volunteer Income Tax Assistance Center director

We recently became aware of an increased number of military members who reported receiving notices from the State of California Franchise Tax Board, stipulating they owed additional state taxes. While all documents from any government agency should be taken very seriously, several military members have reported receiving erroneous tax bills from the FTB and were unsure of how to handle the situation.

If you’ve received a letter similar to what was described, do not panic! Your first step should be to contact the March VITA Office at 951-655-3659 and schedule an appointment with us to review the document. Additionally, FTB Publication 1032 has a wealth of state tax information and is a great resource for military members.

Unfortunately, even when military members accurately prepared their tax returns, there were still instances where some received demand letters from the State. Just last week, a military member requested we review a document that stated he must pay additional state taxes, but after further review, it was determined that the State was in error.

Here is an example that many military members may be able to relate to:

You, the military member and your wife are both Texas residents, stationed in California. Your wife’s income (earned in California) was included in your joint return — is it considered California source income? According to FTB Pub 1032, it does not have to be. To further explain, if you give up your Texas residency for California, then it is, but, if you maintain your Texas residency, it is not. According to the Military Spouse Residence Relief Act, the decision is yours!

The State can also determine if you are required to pay state income tax by analyzing the interest paid on your mortgage. If the amount of interest does not correspond with their perception of what your income should be, then they can assess you with additional state income taxes. The faulty logic used by the State reveals that they do not account for nontaxable income, such as basic allowance for substance or basic allowance for housing. Also, the State is known for not recognizing other nontaxable income such as Veterans Administration disability or social security award payments.

Remember, if you are notified by the State of monies owed, there are ways to handle the situation rather than just surrendering payment.

NEVER, never ignore a state tax demand letter! First, call the State and ask them why they are “purposing” additional taxes against you. If they inform you that it is because they compared your federal return against your state return and determined that you owe more than what you claimed, then the following steps need to be taken:

  • Ensure all communications with the State are conducted in writing for record keeping purposes. Explain in a clear and concise manner that you are a military member living in California by order and that you are not a resident.
  • Submit a copy of your state driver’s license, proving your state residency. In addition, include copies of your W-2s substantiating all of your income and the state which is legally entitled to claim it.
    This should satisfy the State and hopefully dissuade them from further attempts to impose future tax assessments.
    If you are notified that the tax demand is because of your mortgage interest and the state assumes you have more money than you claimed on your state return, then try the following actions:
  • Again, document all your interactions in writing.
  • When submitting your response, it should include all nontaxable income that supports your claim of living within your means. Your letter must list all nontaxable income such as VA disability, BAH.
  • List the yearly amount of the nontaxable income. This should clear the issue up and hopefully it will never happen again.
  • Make sure you follow-up with the State by contacting them in about three weeks, to ensure they have dropped the purposed additional tax demand against you. Also, ask them to send a written resolution stating that the issue has been satisfactorily resolved.

If the State still insists you owe money, contact the March VITA Office and we can review the documents again to determine if both sides fully understand the issue and have seen all the facts. If it is determined that you do owe the money and are unable to pay the entire amount at that time, then you can try to work with the State on an agreeable payment agreement.

Again, the worst thing you can do is to ignore the problem. For questions regarding your taxes or to have us prepare and electronically file your federal and state income taxes for free, please e-mail marchvita@yahoo.com or call 951-655-4479.




All of this week's top headlines to your email every Friday.


 
 

 
U.S. Air Force photo/Senior Airman Russell S. McMillan

Commander shows off Team March at Capitol Hill

U.S. Air Force photo/Senior Airman Russell S. McMillan (From left to right) U.S. Rep. Mark Takano, who represents the 41st District of California, and Julia Steinberger, senior legislative assistant to Takano’s office, discus...
 
 
U.S. Air Force photo/Master Sgt. Megan Crusher

Yellow Ribbon program supports Airman inspired by family history

U.S. Air Force photo/Master Sgt. Megan Crusher Almira Pasic and her youngest son, Memsudin, participate in an activity during the Warrior Support Forum, at a Yellow Ribbon Reintegration Program, held in Chandler, Ariz., July 26...
 
 
Courtesy photo

Through the glass: Veteran remembers his past

Courtesy photo Retired Lt. Col. Bruce Sooy receives a demonstration flight at Nut Tree Airport, Calif., July 2015. It had been 56 years since he had last flown an aircraft. (This feature is part of the “Through Airmen’s Eye...
 

 
Brigade3

News from the 304th Sustainment Brigade’s Facebook page

Army Reserve Pvt. 2nd Class Kiet Duong, a culinary specialist with the 387th, sifts flour through a sieve during the competition. Duong, a Garden Grove, Calif., native, used the flour in the baked wheat rolls and Boston cream c...
 
 
Courtesy photo of Marine Maj. Bridget Guerrero (ret.)

Marine vet honors fallen female troops with 160-mile run

Courtesy photo of Marine Maj. Bridget Guerrero (ret.) Marine Maj. Bridget Guerrero (ret.) ran 160 miles around the Puget Sound in Washington from July 23-26, 2015. Each mile represented a female service member who lost her life...
 
 
150725-F-RK887-023

Swarz assumes command of 452nd Security Forces Squadron

The 452nd Security Forces Squadron held an Assumption of Command ceremony at the Cultural Resource Center here on Saturday, July 25, 2015. During the ceremony Lt. Col. Arthur J. Rodi, deputy commander, 452nd Mission Support Gro...
 




0 Comments


Be the first to comment!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>